The latest update for The Best Gourmet S’mores in NJ is written by Lindsay Podolak.
Got a sweet tooth? One of the most fun desserts — for kids and adults alike — is the s’more. Of course, you can make them at home in the oven or in the yard over a fire; but you can also get gourmet s’mores and other treats at specialty dessert shops across New Jersey.
So slip on your stretchy pants, and prepare to conquer the best sweet treats in the Garden State; because it’s time to showcase the best gourmet s’mores and more in NJ!
Be sure to check each website for COVID-19 updates to store hours and curbside pickup/delivery options.
Quick Click Guide: Select an NJ Region below to find the best Gourmet Desserts near you.
| North Jersey | Central Jersey | Jersey Shore | South Jersey |
More from Best of NJ
North Jersey
Giorgio’s Italian & French Pastry Shop
Where: 112 Washington Street, Hoboken
Gourmet Treat: Cannoli
Details: There’s always a debate among cannoli enthusiasts on who has the best in the state. For more than 35 years, Giorgio Pasticceria Italian Bakery in Hoboken has been winning crowds over with their better-than-Nonna’s homemade treats; but nothing beats the Sicilian-style cannoli. They come in a variety of flavors, but chocolate dipped is always a fan favorite.
Why I like it: Pick up your pastry and enjoy it while strolling downtown Hoboken, a great spot for people-watching.
More Info: No website (they’re that old school) but you can click here to call.
Jersey S’more Company
Where: 16 Jefferson Court, Montville
Gourmet Treat: S’mores (of course)
Details: The Jersey S’more Company in Montville is all about s’mores. First, each handmade s’more begins with a top-secret cookie batter recipe. Then they add the highest quality marshmallow. Finally, they smother the treat in velvety milk, dark, or white chocolate. But there’s more, because they also have great toppings; crushed candies, sweet ‘n’ salty pretzel, toasted coconut, sea salt caramel, peppermint dust, and rainbow sprinkles are just a few examples! The choices are nearly endless.
Why I like it: When the entire menu is all about s’mores, you can expect perfection. Share the love by picking up a large S’monster S’more to thank a teacher or coach for their hard work.
More Info: Click here to visit the website or you can click here to call.
Montclair Bread Company
Where: 113 Walnut Street, Montclair
Gourmet Treat: Maple Bacon Donut
Details: Montclair Bread Company’s donut tower, with mini donuts and donut holes stacked up high, is something of a legend. Even more of a legend is their maple bacon donut. Maple-flavored dough is fried up to puffy perfection and then glazed with more maple and strips of maple bacon for a sweet and salty treat that you won’t soon forget. Have your own idea for a great donut? They can make any flavor and color combo you can come up with. (Such as the now classic Fruity Pebbles donut.)
Why I like it: Having a birthday party? Order a 10” speciality giant donut that will delight your guests!
More Info: Click here to visit the website or you can click here to call.
Sweet Avenue Bakeshop
Where: 153 Park Avenue, Rutherford
Gourmet Treat: S’mores Cupcake
Details: Living a vegan lifestyle, or have a dairy intolerance? Sweet Avenue Bakeshop is New Jersey’s premier vegan bakery, serving up delicious cupcakes made fresh daily. The s’mores cupcake is chocolate cake bursting (and topped) with vanilla-marshmallow frosting, chocolate ganache, gelatin-free marshmallows and graham crackers.
Why I like it: Printed edible image mini cupcakes are available by special order; for example, you can customize birthday treats with any image you want!
More Info: Click here to visit the website or you can click here to call.
Central Jersey
The Chocolate Bar
Where: 112 Quimby Street, Westfield
Gourmet Treat: Gelato
Details: Westfield locals have been enjoying authentic Italian gelato for the past 16 years at The Chocolate Bar. You’ll find the traditional flavors like vanilla, chocolate, and pistachio, but there are also standouts like Razzmatazz; a raspberry gelato with chocolate chips.
Why I like it: The Chocolate Bar has an extensive menu of hand-dipped chocolates. Of course, these make great gifts for loved ones on any occasion.
More Info: Click here to visit the website or you can click here to call.
Jammin’ Crepes
Where: 20 Nassau Street, Princeton
Gourmet Treat: Crepe Cakes
Details: Everyone loves a good crepe, but have you tasted a crepe cake? This delicate dessert is 20 layers of crepes, as well as your favorite fillings and toppings. The Orange Blossom cake (available in gluten-free, too) is a frequent favorite.
Why I like it: They even make tiered wedding cakes, comprised solely of crepes and filling.
More Info: Click here to visit the website or you can click here to call.
Natale’s Summit Bakery
Where: 185 Broad Street, Summit
Gourmet Treat: Philly Fluff Cake
Details: There are lots of cakes, cookies, and pastries at Natale’s, but they’re known for their famous Philly Fluff cake. It’s a soft pound cake that is light, fluffy and moist; it also comes in flavors like blueberry with coffee cake topping.
Why I like it: Pick up a Philly Fluff cake the next time you are entertaining out-of-town guests. It’s big enough to share, plus it will guarantee a return visit!
More Info: Click here to visit the website or you can click here to call.
Jersey Shore
The Flaky Tart
Where: 145 First Ave, Atlantic Highlands
Gourmet Treat: Boston Creme Brioche
Details: This charming neighborhood bakeshop is full of artisan pastries and desserts that are almost too pretty to eat; but you should eat them anyway. Their must-have dessert is the Boston creme brioche. This fluffy homemade donut comes with a glaze of chocolate and pastry cream filling. Seasonal flavors like coconut maple rum and bourbon apple cider with pecans sell out fast, so get there early.
Why I like it: Not only do The Flaky Tart’s pastries taste delicious, their presentation is impeccable. You’ll love the taste, and your Instagram followers will love the look!
More Info: Click here to visit the website or you can click here to call.
The O.G. Creamery
Where: 317 Ocean Gate Avenue, Ocean Gate
Gourmet Treat: Toasty Campfire Donut
Details: The creations here are truly a work of art. Cakes, cupcakes, and donuts, as well as cannolis and more, are all available to satisfy your sweet tooth. However, if you’re a s’mores lover, you’ll want to order the Toasty Campfire Donut. For starters, they dip a plain donut in chocolate icing; then they top it with graham cracker crumbs, chocolate drizzle, marshmallow drizzle, and a torched marshmallow for good measure.
Why I like it: As the name implies, The O.G. Creamery is also an ice cream shop. Their newest flavor, Coconut Almond Joy, is coconut-flavored ice cream with chunks of coconut, chocolate, and almonds.
More Info: Click here to visit the Facebook page or you can click here to call.
Peace Pie
Where: 326 Carpenters Lane, Cape May
Gourmet Treat: S’Mores Peace Pie
Details: Don’t know what a peace pie is? In short, it’s an ice-cream sandwich, but better! Nestled between two cookies is a combo of ice-cream and pie filling. The S’Mores Peace Pie has graham cracker cookies, chocolate ice-cream, chocolate mousse, and marshmallows.
Why I like it: Hard to believe, but they also ship these cool treats straight to your home!
More Info: Click here to visit the website or you can click here to call.
South Jersey
Miel Patisserie
Where: Village Walk Shopping Center, 1990 Route 70 East, Cherry Hill
Gourmet Treat: Macarons
Details: French desserts are the focus at this Cherry Hill patisserie. Of course, you can’t do French without doing macarons, the classic yet oh-so-trendy treat. But at Miel, the flavors change daily and there are gluten-free options. You’ll find that each bite is light with the perfect amount of crispy cookie shell and sweet filling.
Why I like it: Bite-size and beautiful, macarons make the perfect dessert platter for any event; whether it’s a bridal shower, baby shower, or a little girl’s birthday tea party.
More Info: Click here to visit the website or you can click here to call.
The Pop Shop
Where: 1 South Main Street, Medford
Gourmet Treat: Milkshakes
Details: The Collingswood Pop Shop is currently closed until further notice, so you’ll have to head to the Medford location. But we think it’s worth the trip to taste their epic milkshakes. You can always find current specials on social media, like their Strawberry Shortcake milkshake with buttery, rich shortcake on top.
Why I like it: Outside seating and a modern American comfort food menu make this a perfect place for families.
More Info: Click here to visit the website or you can click here to call.
Ray’s
Where: 1225 Haddonfield-Berlin Road, Voorhees
Gourmet Treat: Boozy Cupcakes
Details: Age is just a number, especially if you’re Ray Boutwell, the owner of Ray’s Boozy Cupcakes. Boutwell, a World War II veteran, opened this boozy bakery last year at the age of 92. Flavors rotate daily and include Fireball Chocolate, Sherry Cherry Vanilla, Guinness Stout and many more liquor-infused concoctions. Free samples are always available and yes, there are traditional, alcohol-free cupcakes at the bakery, too.
Why I like it: They can now ship orders of cupcakes by the dozen.
More Info: Click here to visit the Facebook page or you can click here to call.
Hero (Top) Photo: © Jersey S’more Company / Instagram
Other Photos (in Order):
Montclair Bread Company / Facebook
Jammin’ Crepes / Instagram
Peace Pie St. Augustine / Instagram
Ray’s / Facebook
