The word teglia means “roasting pan” in Italian. That’s the meaning behind the name of Teglia Pizza Bar, a new spot in Montclair serving rectangle-shaped pizza. They promise you’ll enjoy fresh, scratch Italian cooking and a crust that’s crisp and chewy, yet light in texture.
The 500-square-foot Teglia Pizza Bar comes with a strong pedigree. Co-owner Joseph Catalano has 30 years of experience as a chef and opening restaurants throughout NJ and NYC. “I grew up in West Orange and always admired the foodie part of Montclair,” Joseph says. He co-owns the spot with Angelo Goncaga, his best friend. “We wanted to create our own opportunity,” he adds. Joseph learned much of his cooking techniques from his father and uncle, both chefs who trained in Italy.
More from Best of NJ
Inside Teglia Pizza Bar, you’ll find metal ceilings, antique-looking fans and lights, and black-and-white marble flooring. Catalano says that the inside – which can seat up to 8 guests – “reminds me of an old Italian coffee bar. So, I made it a pizza bar where you can stop by for a slice or something delicious off the menu at our counter to eat in or take home.”
What’s on the Menu
At the moment, Teglia Pizza Bar focuses its menu on pizza. But more items will be added in the coming weeks. Joseph says the menu is as organic and fresh as possible. For instance, mozzarella and ricotta are made in house. Likewise, he sources products from local shops and farmer’s markets, mixing them with top-notch ingredients from Italy. “I want to make this the best pizza anyone will try.” Click here to see the full menu.
Signature pizzas include the Queen Margarita with fresh mozzarella, tomato, basil, and extra-virgin olive oil; as well as the Roni Cup with pepperoni, sauce, and mozzarella, and the Sweet Heat pie. The latter features cured and fresh Italian sausage with fontina, mozzarella, tomato, basil, and hot honey. However, future plans include both hot and cold sandwiches such as roasted chicken and eggplant parm.
Visit Teglia Pizza Bar at 438 Bloomfield Ave in Montclair. (Click here to find them on Google Maps.) To learn more, click here to visit their website or you can click here to give them a call.
Click here to find the latest restaurants open in New Jersey.
Teglia Pizza Bar FAQs
You can call ahead or use Yelp wait list to make a reservation.
Not yet, but gluten-free crust and other menu items are coming soon.
Yes, and Teglia Pizza Bar will expand their options soon.
They offer takeout, yes.
Yes, they offer delivery through Slice and ChowNow.
No, they do not serve alcohol.
They do not have a kids’ menu, no.
All Photos: © Teglia Pizza Bar / Instagram
