Forget fast fashion: Thrifting is where style meets sustainability. Luckily, New Jersey is packed with consignment boutiques, antique shops, and thrift stores perfect for savvy shoppers. For those who want to shop smart, support good causes, and source their fashion sustainably, thrifting is essential. Which is why we’re sharing a list of NJ’s Best Spots for Thrifting.
Whether hunting for Y2K streetwear, vintage Levi’s, designer steals, or vintage home decor, NJ’s thrift scene is a goldmine. Of course, not all thrift stores are created equal. Some are treasure chests overflowing with rare finds. Ready to uncover hidden gems, score insane deals, and build a one-of-a-kind wardrobe? Check out this list of The Best Shops for Thrifting in New Jersey.
Quick Click Guide: Select an NJ Region to see the Best Shops for Thrifting nearby.
| North Jersey | Central Jersey | Jersey Shore | South Jersey |
North Jersey
Featured from Bergen County:
Mikayla’s Thriftique
Where: 155 Park Ave, Rutherford
Details: Named after Owner Sara Henderson’s daughter, Mikayla’s Thriftique carefully curates pre-loved items for the entire family. The store is committed to preserving the historic character of the items they sell as well as the historic Holman building where the business resides. Their selection includes vintage and brand-name clothing, costume & fine jewelry, children’s toys, classic/modern books, and retro housewares. Other finds range from pet accessories and small-to-mid-size furniture to unique works of art. Of course, thrifters will also find throwback/fashion handbags & accessories, collectibles, movies & music, antiques and more. The shop’s goal is to carry quality items at low prices in a welcoming boutique-style setting. Stop in regularly to find weekly hauls of sustainable gems and thrifting favorites. Parents will also appreciate that the space has a kids’ corner to keep little ones occupied while the adults shop. Keep in mind, Mikayla’s Thriftique accepts donations but it is not a consignment shop.
| Visit Their Website | Follow on Instagram | Call 201-499-1177 |
Another Man’s Treasure Vintage Store
Where: Jersey City
Details: Established in 2006, Another Man’s Treasure is now a cornerstone for vintage enthusiasts. They offer a meticulously-curated collection of clothing and accessories spanning from the Victorian era to the 1990s. Owners Meika and Warren Franz infuse their passion and expertise into sourcing unique pieces: thus ensuring an ever-evolving inventory that keeps fashion aficionados returning. Thanks to its prime location near the Grove Street PATH station, this shop is a must-visit for classic finds.
B. Savvy Consignment & Accessory Boutique
Where: Roseland
Details: This upscale consignment shop is popular for its selection of sustainable fashion. They specialize in jewelry and accessories, handbags, apparel, and shoes. This includes items from high-end brands such as Louis Vuitton, Fendi, Gucci, and Tory Burch. Their strict consignment guidelines ensure every item available for purchase is clean, in perfect condition, and no more than 2-3 years old. Items can be purchased in-store or online and shipped anywhere. Visit their website to find the complete list of brands they accept.
DBLTKE Luxury Consignment Boutique
Where: Short Hills
Details: For luxury lovers with a taste for designer fashion, without the designer price tag, DoubleTake (DBLTKE) delivers. This boutique consignment shop specializes in authenticated high-end brands like Chanel, Gucci, and Louis Vuitton. Expect carefully curated racks of pristine second-hand pieces, from handbags to evening wear. Shopping here feels exclusive yet approachable, with expert staff ready to help thrifters discover their next signature look. DBLTKE is the spot for anyone that believes fashion should be both sustainable and stunning.
Duet Curated Consignment
Where: Livingston
Details: Duet Curated Consignment offers a thoughtful selection of high-end designer clothing and accessories. Thrifty fashion enthusiasts know it’s an amazing spot to find luxury brands at accessible prices. In addition, the boutique’s commitment to quality and style ensures that each piece meets discerning standards. This makes Duet a premier destination for those seeking to enhance their wardrobe sustainably. Plan a trip during their end of season markdowns to maximize savings and walk out with a veritable treasure trove.
eDesigner Resale
Where: Cliffside Park
Details: eDesigner Resale specializes in offering a wide range of designer clothing and accessories, ensuring quality and authenticity. The boutique provides fashion-forward thrifters with an opportunity to acquire luxury items at a fraction of their original cost. This makes them a fan-favorite consignment shop for anyone seeking to elevate their style sustainably. Interestingly, they use an AI system called Entrupy to help authenticate their luxury items and sneakers. This helps the team quickly verify an item’s authenticity.
Hamburg Antique Center
Where: Hamburg
Details: This center’s diverse selection caters to both seasoned collectors and casual shoppers. In particular, Hamburg Antique Center features over 40 individual vendors offering vintage furniture, collectibles, and unique finds. The family-owned atmosphere makes it a destination for community members seeking distinctive pieces with historical charm. While the business itself recently celebrated its 20-year anniversary, the vendors themselves have decades more experience curating desirable antiques.
Market Street Mission Thrift Store
Where: Morristown
Details: This isn’t just a thrift store, it’s a hidden gem filled with incredible deals on clothing, furniture, and décor. Plus, every transaction supports meaningful causes such as providing meals for the homeless and restoring families. Whether hunting for stylish second-hand fashion or rare home accents, their ever-changing inventory ensures each visit is new. Combining unbeatable prices and a feel-good mission, Main Street Mission is thrifting at its best. Visit their website for volunteer opportunities, or support resources for challenges like addiction.
Montclair Antique Center
Where: Montclair
Details: Montclair Antique Center is a group shop housing over 50 antique dealers. This allows them to provide a varied selection of American and Continental antiques from the 19th and 20th centuries. The center’s extensive collection includes furniture, art, and collectibles, appealing to enthusiasts and decorators alike. They are conveniently located on Church St, the epicenter of Montclair’s dining, entertainment, and shopping district. Which means a stop here is the perfect addition to a group day trip with fellow thrifters.
One Savvy Design Consignment Boutique
Where: Upper Montclair
Details: Owned by a seasoned fashion professional, One Savvy Design Consignment Boutique provides authenticated new and gently used designer items. The boutique’s curated selection ensures that clients have access to high-quality fashion pieces at marked down prices. Thrifters agree One Savvy Design is a go-to destination for anyone looking to enhance their wardrobe with luxury brands. Plus, their selection of new merchandise means their inventory is always stocked with the latest trendy clothing and accessories.
Passaic Thrift
Where: Passaic
Details: Step inside Passaic Thrift Store and prepare for a treasure hunt! This spacious, well-organized store makes it easy to browse through racks of high-quality clothing, accessories, and home goods. From trendy pieces to timeless classics, they offer incredible finds at prices that make splurging guilt-free. The best part? The clean and friendly atmosphere makes second-hand shopping feel like a boutique experience. Thrifting pros and first-timers alike know that Passaic Thrift Store is the go-to spot for that next great find.
The Andover Village
Where: Andover
Details: The Andover Village is a collection of antique and vintage stores. Their combined inventory provides a wide variety of collectibles, jewelry, furniture, and home décor. The village’s diverse array of shops provides a rich selection for those seeking unique and historical items. This makes it a popular spot for antique enthusiasts as well as those looking for unique accents and decor for their garden. It’s also worth noting that they accept sports apparel, so families can occasionally find items including vintage catcher’s gloves.
Udelco
Where: Hawthorne
Details: Udelco is a treasure trove of vintage clothing from the 1960s, 70s, 80s, and 90s. It’s an amazing place to get thrifty, as they sell a wide variety of clothing at amazing prices. The warehouse-style setting is perfect for adventurous shoppers who want to spend the day in search of treasure. Not surprisingly, their extensive collection makes Udelco a popular destination for those seeking unique vintage apparel. The business just recently celebrated 25 years in Hawthorne, but is actually more than 50 years old.
Central Jersey
Featured from Union County:
Junior League of Summit Thrift Shop
Where: 37 Deforest Ave, Summit
Details: The Junior League of Summit Thrift Shop is Summit’s oldest retailer, in operation for 90 years. This women-owned and operated business offers an extensive selection of items worth sifting through. Their selection includes high-quality apparel for women, men, and children, along with housewares, jewelry, shoes, accessories, and novelty items. A commitment to presentation, meticulous merchandising, and fast product turnover helps them stand apart from other thrift stores. They cultivate a boutique-like atmosphere across two floors with items organized by category. But the best part is that thrifters can find great scores while also supporting even better causes. Proceeds from the shop supports grants, scholarships, training, and local projects in our four surrounding communities.
| Visit Their Website | Follow on Instagram | Follow on Facebook | Call 908-273-7344 |
Elysium Antiques
Where: Somerville
Details: Elysium Antiques is a charming shop known for its exceptional vintage jewelry collection, home decorations, small collectibles, and art pieces. The boutique’s curated selection appeals to those seeking unique and timeless items This makes it a well-regarded destination for antique enthusiasts and collectors. For those with something to sell, keep an eye out for their monthly Free Appraisal Day. It’s the perfect time to bring by any items worth parting with, while also finding something new to bring home.
Greene Street
Where: Princeton
Details: Greene Street is Princeton’s worst-kept secret for sustainable, stylish fashion. This is where smart shoppers find high-end designer pieces at steep discounts. From J.Crew to Balenciaga, their selection includes modern elegance and timeless favorites. Clothing, accessories, and shoes arrive daily, making every visit an opportunity to score an incredible deal. Plus, the upscale, boutique-style setting makes second-hand shopping feel effortlessly chic. This is the place to be to build a conscious wardrobe without sacrificing style.
My Unique Thrift Shop
Where: Elizabeth | South Plainsfield | Union City | Union Township | Watchung
Details: Thrifters looking for a vast selection of clothing, accessories, and household items at affordable prices need look no further. My Unique Thrift Shop offers an organized layout and frequent inventory updates. This lets shoppers consistently refresh their wardrobe or home décor without breaking the bank. It’s also a great place for bargain hunters to find specialized apparel such as wedding dresses, sports memorabilia, and more. As a larger chain, they are able to offer steep discounts — 25% – 75% off — on new items every day.
Plato’s Closet
Where: Middletown | Lawrence Township | Edison
Details: While we don’t typically include larger chains in our lists, Plato’s Closet is Gen Z’s favorite spot for thrifting. That’s largely because the popular spot specializes in trendy, gently used clothing and accessories for teens and young adults. The store offers cash on the spot for items they select, making it a convenient option for sellers as well. There’s no two ways about it, Plato’s Closet let’s young fashionistas update their wardrobe at a fraction of retail prices. It’s the most economically conscious place to find trendy and unique styles.
Revive Consignment
Where: Somerville
Details: Step into Revive and experience consignment shopping redefined. This boutique carries a carefully-curated selection of clothing and accessories from casual cool to red carpet-ready. Unlike fast fashion, these hand-picked pieces are built to last, offering designer finds at a fraction of the price. Thrifters who live for the thrill of finding a one-of-a-kind outfit have to check out Revive. Their selection is the perfect blend of sustainability and fashion-forward style, boasting finds shoppers won’t find anywhere else.
Summit Antiques Center
Where: Summit
Details: Summit Antiques Center is a must-visit for thrifters who love history, craftsmanship, and timeless beauty. This multi-dealer marketplace is a wonderland for antiques, vintage jewelry, rare collectibles, and statement furniture. Their diverse selection means shoppers of all tastes can find what they need; whether furnishing a space with Victorian elegance or hunting for the perfect Art Deco conversation piece. Knowledgeable vendors make the hunt more rewarding, ensuring anyone can leave with something authentic, special, and story-worthy.
The People’s Store Antiques and Design Center
Where: Lambertville
Details: The People’s Store is an essential stop for serious collectors and casual browsers alike. Each floor of this four-story antique paradise offers something new, from rare furniture and vintage books to fine art and historical oddities. Lambertville is already known as New Jersey’s antique capital, and this shop embodies that spirit perfectly. Their ever-changing inventory of unbelievable finds will reward thrifters looking for statement pieces or investment-worthy treasures. Exploring this 1839 landmark feels like stepping back in time.
Jersey Shore
Antique Center of Red Bank
Where: Red Bank
Details: With over 100 dealers spread across two historic buildings, this isn’t just an antique shop: it’s an adventure. The Antique Center of Red Bank offers a mix of vintage furniture, exquisite silver, old-world décor, and retro fashion. They offer something for everyone, including thrifters on the hunt for a statement piece. In business now for over 60 years, this is a place where the past meets the present in unforgettable ways. Determined explorers are sure to find their next favorite treasure here.
Antique Emporium of Asbury Park
Where: Asbury Park
Details: An adventurer’s paradise, Antique Emporium spans 20,000 square feet of antique wonders. It’s a beloved spot for vintage enthusiasts, featuring everything from old Hollywood memorabilia to rare Victorian furniture. They have everything a savvy shopper needs to furnish a home, or simply find the perfect nostalgic accent. Antique Emporium is packed with fascinating pieces that are as much conversation starters as they are collectibles. But the most vintage aspect of this spot just might be their prices.
Luxe & Shadows
Where: Red Bank
Details: Luxe and Shadows — formerly known as Backward Glances — is a vintage and alternative style boutique. Their curated selection boasts period clothing, antique jewelry, and unique accessories from the 1800s through the 1980s. The shop’s eclectic collection will appeal to anyone looking to find distinctive fashion pieces and nostalgic items. From eye-catching holiday outfits to last-minute gifts for friends, it’s a great shop for a quick purchase. Keep an eye out for special sales, like during Small Business Saturday, to save big.
Deja Vu NJ Consignment
Where: Point Pleasant Beach
Details: Deja Vu specializes in pre-owned women’s clothing, including designer shoes and accessories. The “upscale resale boutique’s” commitment to quality and style ensures that clients find fashionable items at reasonable prices. This is perfect for thrifters who want to enhance their wardrobe sustainably. They don’t have a website, but are active on social media such as Facebook and Instagram. Follow along to see their latest inventory highlights along with notifications about sales.
Mill House Antiques
Where: Long Branch
Details: For thrifters looking to find items that mix elegance with history, Mill House Antiques is the place to be. They specialize in gorgeous antique lighting, furniture, and decorative pieces. Statements pieces abound as they curate a selection of chandeliers, sconces, and lanterns from different eras. From rustic farmhouse charm to sophisticated European antiques, Mill House Antiques provides furnishings with a focus on old-world character. Can’t make it in person? They also have an eBay store with special pricing on select items.
Squan Dry Goods
Where: Manasquan | Point Pleasant
Details: Squan Dry Goods is the go-to spot for thrifters with a taste for bohemian, vintage, and alternative fashion. The trendy consignment boutique carries an ever-changing mix of funky wardrobe staples. Highlights include vintage denim, band tees, sundresses, and iconic Doc Martens. Visit Squan Dry Goods when it’s time for a closet refresh or just to find a unique statement piece. Younger shoppers love the selection of affordable, effortlessly cool fashion as well as the laid-back, surf-town setting.
The Center Square Thrift Shop
Where: Belmar
Details: The Center Square is no ordinary thrift shop. It’s a non-profit run by a local organization that gives back in a number of ways. Shopping here not only nets thrifters gently used clothing, home décor, and unique vintage pieces; it also supports housing programs, behavior health and wellness programs, nutrition programs, and referral services for those in need. The inventory is constantly rotating, so every visit brings new surprises at bargain prices. Come find a hidden treasure while giving back to the community!
South Jersey
Clutter Vintage Shop
Where: Collingswood
Details: Clutter Vintage Shop is the perfect stop for fans of quirky, one-of-a-kind vintage pieces. They specialize in retro fashion, mid-century furniture, kitschy home décor, and pop culture memorabilia. Basically, Clutter is a nostalgic wonderland for collectors and vintage lovers. The owners have an eye for the cool and unusual; which makes this a must-visit for creatives, artists, and vintage fashionistas looking for conversation-starting finds at reasonable prices. Plus, they’re open on weekends for convenient day trips.
Thrift Village
Where: Glassboro
Details: This massive thrift store offers everything from clothing and shoes to furniture, electronics, and home goods. Thrift Village boasts racks upon racks of deeply discounted merchandise, making it a favorite among budget-conscious shoppers. However, it’s also the preferred thrifting destination for DIY upcyclers, and college students looking for dorm essentials. With a huge selection and frequent markdowns, unbelievable deals are around every corner. Bring some friends and a discerning eye, and walk out with a bounty of treasures.
Twice Loved Treasures
Where: Vineland
Details: Twice Loved Treasures is a charming thrift and consignment shop. The walls are filled with unique home décor, vintage furniture, and stylish second-hand clothing. It’s the perfect place to find hidden gems that add character to any space or wardrobe. The store is clean, well-organized, and known for its friendly staff and unbeatable prices. For thrifters on the hunt for an accent piece, or those who want to be surprised, this shop never disappoints. Purchases here benefit Inspira Health, a local non-profit healthcare organization.
Click Here To See More Best of New Jersey Lists.
Thrifting Shops in New Jersey FAQ
Top Photo: © One Savvy Design / Facebook